We Would Suffer
Welp, I have zero survival skills, my best friend doesn't really either, I can't cook, neither can my friend. I'm allergic to most fish - unlike my friend, the sun hates me - don't know about my friend. I'm afraid of anything with an antennae - so is my friend, as well as creatures capable of crawling on you (ie. crabs, lobsters, scorpions, those eigth-legged-unmentionables, etc), and my best friend... has a boyfriend who she'd probably have to get back to sooner or later.
Essentially, we would suffer.
So unless this island came with snow (the ultimate sun-repellant), a cabin, my best friend's artsy tools, a dungeon to keep my best friend's boyfriend in so I wouldn't have to deal wi- *cough* - I mean...
>_>
<_<
video game consoles, an online shopping system to get the newest games for these consoles, a robot chef who would'nt start up a conversation with us, and my laptop so I can be an author in peace... then we wouldn't be happy.
However... if this was an island, in a certain seperate dimension that we both know and love, and where my friend and I have easy access to our dragons, then most of these problems wouldn't exist.